Please note: this text may be incomplete. For more information about this OCR, view
About OCR text.
March i6, 1907
RECOKD AND GUIDE
531
— .^^ -.
ESTABDSHED^ M.ftRCH£!^^ 1B68.
DEviriEBpRfA.LESTAn-BuiLDlf(G ^ROdTECTUHE.HoUSEllOLDDEGOFiATlOlJ,
Bl/Sl^/Ess a(1dThemes OF GeKeraV If/TER^Esi,
PRICE PER YEAR IN ADVANCE EIGHT DOLLARS
Published every Saturday
Communications should lie addreasod to
C. W. SWEET
Downtown Oflice; 14-16 Vesey Street, New York
Tolephono, Cortlaudt 3157
Uptown Office: I 1-13 East 24th Street, New York
Teleplione, 4430 M.iciiaon Squuro
''Entered at the Post Office at S'ev.' York. A'. Y., as second-class mallei:"
Copyright by C. W. Sweet. _______
Vol. LXXIX.
MARCH 16, 1907.
No. 2035.
INDEX TO DEPARTMENTS.
Advertising Section.
Page Page
Cement ....................xvii Lumber.....................xx
Consulting Engineers........viii Machinery...................vi
Clay Products .................ix Meta! Work.................xvi
Contractors and Builders......iii Quick Job Directory.........xxiii
Electrical Interests ...........vii Real Estate ...................xl
Fireprooflng ...................ii Roofers & Roofing Materials.xxii
Granite ...................xviii Stone ....................xviii
Iron and Steel ................x Wood Products...............xx
WHAT may be called a series of severe earthquake
shoclcs have taken place this week in Wall Street,
which at this writing is still in the throes of seismic dis-
turhances. Wednesday there was a general brealt in prices
and enormous selling brought such widespread liquidation
that scarcely any security escaped serious loss. Then came
a slight rally, hut the floodgates of distrust and want of con¬
fidence were open, and Thursday's and yesterday's market be¬
gan to assume quite a panicky aspect, verging on collapse.
Union Pacific, Steel and Reading were tlie principal sufferers.
Speculation as to the cause of this state of things is useless in
view of the actual facts. In the Northern Pacific corner May 9,
1901, the average drop of a score of railroad stocks was
over $S a share. .This week's slump was considerably more
than that. Rumors, no doubt, helped to bring about the
decline, but these rumors, as it was subsequently proved, had
little or no foundation. It was said that London was talk¬
ing of the probability of an increase in the discount rate
of the Banli of England, but even had this been the case, that
would fail to explain the precipitate drop in prices. Then
it was stated that the Banl; of France was going to raise
rates, aud from Germany tliere was talk of the impending
failure of a large banking firm in close relation with a prom¬
inent house in New York. Both concerns, it was alleged,
held enormous amounts of American securities, especially
those tliat had had their paper values seriously impaired.
It subsequently transpired that there was no element of
truth in these rumors, but the mere publication had evi¬
dently done its destructive work, or at least had helped to
do so. The decline certainly began abroad, London sold
Americans for its own account almost simultaneously with
the receipt of the Kew York orders, and thousands of shares
were sold for the account of European centres of flnance.
The actual amount of shrinkage.or depreciation iu the stock
market this week cannot be far from $400,000,000, if it
does not exceed that sum. Money, as a matter of course,
fluctuated considerably. It opened on Wednesday at 6 per
cent., then advanced to 7%, and as liquidation progressed,
it reached a maximum of 15 per cent.,- only to decline later
to 5 per cent. Until Wall Street, therefore, has settled down
to normal conditions, it is futile to discuss the question or
what rates for money may be. It is claimed by some Wall
Street authorities that the "panic" was made to order by
railroad magnates in order to frighten everybody and make
President Roosevelt declare what his intentions were re¬
garding railroad legislation.
SENATOR PAGE has introduced a bill into the Legisla-
ture, providing for the appointment of a charter-re¬
vision commission, and in as much as Governor Hughes and
Mayor McClellan have both approved the idea, it is to be
expected that the bill will pass. Its passage, moreover,
would be an excellent thing. The charter of this city is a
very much revised instrnment; but much as it has been re¬
vised, it is still very far from being perfect. Moreover it is
imperfect chiefly because its revisers have in the past failed
to apply certain fundamental and fruitful principles in a
thorough-going manner. A city needs, above all, a strong,
centralized, responsible and efficient government—a gov¬
ernment which possesses full powers and can be held to
strict accountability. Experience has proved that a City
Council cannot, under American conditions, be made the
basis of such a government, and that the necessary powers
and responsibilities are too considerable to bestow on any
one mau. They can, however, be bestowed upon a com¬
mission, and the Board of Estimate and Apportionment
should be granted just as much authority over the affairs of
the municipality as have the Board of Directors over the
affairs of a private corporation. The Mayor and the other
executive officials should be the servants of the Board, The
Aldermen should be abolished entirely, because they at pres¬
ent are a costly and even a baleful excrescence. The Bor¬
ough Presidents should be deprived of seats on the Board
and should be appointed rather than elected officials. Their
powers should, moreover, be considerably reduced, and their
present independence substantially curtailed. Their inde¬
pendence has not worked advantageously, because tliey have
no interest except in their own boroughs, and their sole
purpose is to get as much money as possible out of the city
to spend in their special localities. The Board of Directors
of a railroad might just as well make a division superin¬
tendent au independent official. Finally the revised charter
should be framed so that in the powers it grants to the
Governing Board, the paramount importance of general
street improvements should be recognized. The present
local boards of improvement have worked inefficiently and
always will do so. Alterations in the lines of streets are of
much more general than they are --of local importance, and
local interests should not be allowed to block improvements
which are of the utmost importance to the whole city.
The Situation in Respect to Rapid Transit.
Now that the Seventh and Eighth Avenue subway routes
are coming up for final decision, many voices are again
being raised against the opportunity which is offered by the
character of the route to the Interborough Company. It
is being violently asserted that the city should not make it so
easy for the Interborough Company to bid, and that the
interest of the people of New York demands new subways
which complete rather than connect with the existing sub¬
way. The Record aud Guide entirely and emphatically dis¬
sents from such an opinion. The interest of the people of
New York City will be promoted by the gradual extension
of the existing subway system, provided the Interborough
Company will lease these extensions on terms which are
fair to the city. New York should not submit for a moment
to any proposal on the part of the company which looked in
the direction of a longer lease than that provided by the
present rapid transit law. If the' Interborough Company
refuses to bid for an operating privilege running twenty
years with an extension running the same period, the city
must simply stand pat and'seek another bidder. If such
another bidder cannot be found the city should itself butid
and equip an independent belt line and lease it for as many
years as may be necessary to an independent operating com¬
pany. Not on any account should New York alienate the
new subways for a longer period than forty years, because
the experience of other large cities convincingly proves that
a longer lease is simply giving money away to the operating
company. But if the Interborough Company will accept a
lease for twenty plus twenty years, there is every reason in
the world why the city should permit the new subways to
be connected with the existing subway. Other things being
equal, it is far better for New York to be served by a single
rapid transit company, whose lines connect one with another
and whose system can be operated as a unit. New York
would be cutting off its nose to spite its face in case it dis¬
criminated against the Interborough Company in planning
its subway extensions. That company is in a position, by
means of transfers and connections, to give the travelling
public a far better service than could any other corporation,
and every proof should be given that the city is not only
ready but willing to do business ou fair terms with Bel¬
mont & Co. Such is the real meaning of the chance for al¬
ternative bids which is offered by the peculiar character
of the proposed new Seventh Avenne and Lexington Avenue
routes. The Interborough Company is offered thereby an
opportunity to enter into relations with the city, which may
be very profitable both to New York and to the company,
while at the same time competition is stimulated by afford¬
ing an independent company the chance of building and
operating a wholly independent system. If the Interborough